Compressor surge and stall 1st edition by ronald c. A stall condition is caused by a pressure ratio that is incompatible with the engine rpm. The small pt6 will stall and surge at higher speeds if the bleed valve closes to early but will very often have no stall tendancy above about 92% when the valve is closed in other words it will be transient from the point of early closing to a point where the engine has reached a speed that the valve should be closed. Compressor stall and surge university of cambridge. If the bungee cord has no losses to dampen the oscillation, we have something akin to surge. This can happen at startup, during rapid acceleration from low rpm, or during a sudden reduction of mass airflow, when a few or all the stages. The compressor blade on the right is in stalled condition.
An alternative type of stall is a compressor surge. Axial compressor stall and surge prediction by measurements h. A surge is unique to the engine which has a higher pressure contained behind the compressor which is stalling. Pdf modeling and control of surge and rotating stall in. The phenomena of stall and surge in axialcentrifugal compressors is in vestigated through highresponse measurements of both the pressure. To understand the concept behind stalling and surging, we should first know the flow over an airfoil. Compressor aerodynamic instabilities are generally categorized in two distinct classes. Surge is a complete breakdown of steady flow through the compressor. Study of compressor instabilities such as surge and rotating stall has received much attention in recent years. Keywords axial compressor centrifugal compressor compression system compressor characteristic inlet guide vane. Compressor stall aircraft turbine engine aviation glossary. Modeling and control of surge and rotating stall in compressors. Extending the operating range of compressors offers the potential for increased pressure rise and improved efficiency.
Now we will see how the surge starts in a compressor. Surge is violent instability characterized by onedimensional fluctuation in. It is defined as the lower limit of stable operation of the compressor. Compressor stall a compressor stall is a local disruption of the airflow in a gas turbine or turbocharger compressor. Unsteady compressor operating point at design speed during stall inception and stall recovery. The surge can result in a condition known as compressor stall, which stops the compressor and can cause serious damage. Stall recovery at a fixed throttle setting dashed lines occurs 0.
Pampreen 1973 found that the clearance loss of a centrifugal compressor can be. Surging and stalling both lead to unstable flow in compressors. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Centrifugal compressor surge, modeling and identification. Mechanism of stall and surge in a centrifugal compressor. In the case of turbine engines, like jet airplane engines, a surge which. This was a test flight to find out why that engine had compressor stalls at altitude.
A compressor going into stall is like jumping off a cliff with a bungee cord. An operating curve of a gas turbine engine, which shows the relationship. What is surging choking and stalling in compressor mecholic. Several surge cycles can occur due to delays and lags in high temperature, thrust, and vibration shutdown systems. When a centrifugal compressor surges, there is an actual reversal of gas flow through the compressor impeller.
During the display at the zeltweg airshow in austria, the belgian air force f16 suffered a compressor stall that caused a loud bang and an impressive backfire. Compressor stall recovery through tip injection assessed. It is a phenomena accompanied by centrifugal compressors having continuous flow rate, gas path inside compressor flows having an acceptable value of eddies and vortices but if these eddies and vortices. Honen institutjftr strahlantriebe undturboarbeitsmaschinen, rwthaachen aachen university oftechnology, 52062aachen, germany received3 april 1997. The course of the surge is decreasing mass flow rate and increases a rotational speed of the impeller. Professional development program compressor surge and stall. The instability is characterized by large limit cycle oscillations in compressor. Surge is a system dependant phenomenon associated to large amplitude oscillations of the pressure through the compressor system 1. The surge usually starts in one stage of a multistage compressor and can occur very rapidly.
Compressor stallin the worst case scenario the aviationist. Engine compressor will stall if the compressor is operated above the surge line. When the diffuser vane angle is adjusted positively which means the airflow incidence angle at the diffuser inlet increases, the aerodynamic load is increased, and the instability of the vaneless region between the impeller and the diffuser is. These factors may aggravate to a state of local breakdown of flow or a total breakdown of flow or with a. Compressor rotating stall, surge, and its control hindawi. This occurs when the angle of attack of the blades of the compressor exceed their critical angle of attack resulting in one or more stages of rotor blades failing to pass air smoothly to the succeeding stages. Compressor surge and stall ghent university library. A compressor stall in a gas turbine engine is a condition in an axialflow compressor in which one or more stages of rotor blades fail to pass air smoothly to the succeeding stages. In the vicinity of the stall line, the flow field is inherently unsteady due to the interactions between adjacent rows of blades, formation of small stall cells, flow separation and the viscous effects including shockboundary layer interactions. Global stability and control analysis of axial compressor stall and surge phenomena using bifurcation methods n ananthkrishnan1,ugvaidya2andvwwalimbe3 1indian institute of technology bombay, powai, mumbai, india 2university of california, santa barbara, ca, usa 3georgia institute of technology, atlanta, ga, usa abstract. Active controllers that allow the compressor to operate safely at its. The mechanism of stall and surge in the compressor differs at different diffuser vane angles.
A particular kind of stall is the socalled compressor surge is a complete breakdown in compression that occurs when compressors blades stall airfoils just like an airplane wing stalls. Compressor loadsharing control and surge detection techniques wayne jacobson global technology manager compressor controls corporation des moines, ia, usa medhat zaghloul regional manager abu dhabi compressor controls corporation al reem island, abu dhabi, uae michael tolmatsky director research and development. Stall is found in dynamic compressors, particularly axial compressors, as used in jet engines and turbochargers for reciprocating engines compressor stalls result in a loss of compressor performance, which can vary in severity from a momentary engine power drop. Watch an f16 suffer a compressor stall during the display. A compressor surge is flow through a compressor that is against the direction of flow during normal operation or an oscillating flow in both directions. A tapered duct improves surge margin, isentropic efficiency and pressure ratio. Modification of axialflow compressor stall margin by. Modeling and control advances in industrial control. Rotating stall and surge, known as the typical flow instability for compressors, can be loosely characterized as the pressure breakdown as the mass flow decreases. A cd nozzle improves surge margin, isentropic efficiency and noise emissions. Modification of axialflow compressor stall margin by variation of stationary blade setting angles john paul rukavina iowa state university follow this and additional works at. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading compressor surge and rotating stall.
An improperly designed surge control system can lead to multiple surge events increasing the risk to personnel safety and major damage to the compressor. An aerofoil stalls when the air flow completely separates from the top side or s. A compressor stall in a jet engine is a circumstance of abnormal airflow resulting from the aerodynamic stall of aerofoils compressor blades within the compressor. There are many station events that can cause a centrifugal compressor to surge, such as interaction with other units, reciprocating compressor pulsations, and upset conditions like sudden. Compressor surge and stall ronald c pampreen published in 1993 in norwich by concepts eti services. Study of compressor instabilities such as surge and rotating stall has received. The surge is starting with the instant flow reverses, shown in the above figure. Surge description flow reverses in 20 to 50 milisec. Surge rotating stall in compressors dring thesis jan t omm y gra vdahl rep ort w departmen t of engineering cyb ernetics norw egian univ ersit y of science and t ec hnology n t rondheim norw a y. The effect of several inlet geometries on compressor performance is investigated. Surge control design for centrifugal compressor systems.
Pdf previous work on stabilization of compressor surge is extended to include. In this case, the problem is caused by unexpectedly high pressure in the combustion chamber or in the compressor, which forces its way forward as well as backwards, against the incoming flow rate. Over the last 75 years these compressors have been improved continuously, today achieving component efficiencies of more than 90%. The work is motivated by the fundamental instability problem of surge and rotating stall which limits the range of operation for compressors at low mass flows. Modeling and control advances in industrial control kindle edition by gravdahl, jan tommy, egeland, olav. An investigation of surge in a highspeed centrifugal. Sustain oscillation important element it protects the compressor from surge over the range of compressor operations.
Axialflow compressors are used in the majority of large gas turbines, both in powerplants and aircraft jet engines. This is the first of a threepart series by the author. A condition in which the compressor blades stall as the relative airflow meets the blades beyond the critical angle. Cp5059 continual assessment ay202014 s2 dche 2a21 joshua miaoqi yihuan yunya. Global stability and control analysis of axial compressor. A compressor surge control system linkedin slideshare. Compressor stallmargin curve article about compressor. The severity of the phenomenon ranges from a momentary power drop barely registered by the engine instruments to a complete loss of compression in case of a surge. This article explains surge phenomena and discusses why the antisurge protection system is a very important part of a compressor surge. At low flow rates, rotating stall and surge are the fundamental limits of a compressors operating range. A stall that results in the complete disruption of the airflow through the compressor is referred to as a compressor surge.
In addition, surge avoidance measures such as recycle and bleed have significant negative effects on energy consumption and should preferably be avoided kim and fleeter, 1994. Once the higher pressure overcomes the loss of pressure from a stalled stage than the air will reverse itself and come forward out of the inlet with a loud bang. Cumpsty 1989 and pampreen 1993 differentiate between progressive and abrupt stall, and full span or. The closer the operating point is to the surge line, the greater the pressure ratio achieved by the compressor, but the greater the risk of stall or surge. Find out information about compressor stallmargin curve. Compressor surge and stall detection and prevention tips. Section 3 description of surge 31 surge versus stall surge is a dynamic instability that occurs in dynamic compressors. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
Rotating stall is characterized by the presence of one or several cells rotating around the annulus, either in the impeller or in the diffuser. Compressor loadsharing control and surge detection. Compressor surge and stall compressor surge and stall ronald c. Infinalform 10 july 1997 the paper deals with experimental investigations and analyses ofunsteady pressure distributionsin different. The compressor system instability and control have been an inherently challenging problem for turbomachinery community since the advent of the gas turbine engine. Effect of the inlet geometry on performance, surge margin. A compressor stall is a local disruption of the airflow in the compressor of a gas turbine or turbocharger. These instabilities lead the compressor to rotating stall or surge. Compressor stall article about compressor stall by the. It is related to compressor surge which is a complete disruption of the flow through the compressor. A compressor stall is a situation of abnormal airflow resulting from a stall of the aerofoils within the compressor of a jet engine.
496 1179 419 806 472 974 542 430 1441 426 213 91 1330 1293 565 1200 149 1113 1330 354 1060 388 713 246 410 931 195 339 1250 1105 1100 1076 916 981 39 1346 824 340